Marvel and NCSoft Settle Lawsuit Over “City of Heroes”

Not much in the way of details, but late last year Marvel settled its lawsuit against NCSoft, makers of MMORPG “City of Heroes.”

Marvel had sued NCSoft saying the ability of players to make characters that looked very similar to Marvel heroes represented copyright and trademark infringements.

This was pretty clearly a defeat for Marvel given that a press release from NCSoft announcing the settlement said,

The parties’ settlement allows them all to continue to develop and sell exciting and innovative products, but does not reduce the players’ ability to express their creativity in making and playing original and exciting characters. Therefore, no changes to City of Heroes or City of Villains’ character creation engine are part of the settlement.

I’ve actually been playing a bit of CoH ever since I kicked my WoW addiction. It is a pretty good game, though not nearly as compelling or enjoyable as WoW was.

At least when I play, I rarely see rip-offs of DC or Marvel characters. That’d be pretty boring anyway. Currently I’m playing The CandiMan. After all, who can stop criminals in their tracks? The CandiMan can!

Source:

Marvel vs. City of Heroes lawsuit settled. GameWinners.Com, December 15, 2005.

Jon Udell on Silly Privacy Screwups

InfoWorld’s Jon Udell writes about the the silly security holes that can exist when people obsess about forms and internal data security and don’t take a step back to look at a system as a whole.

In the example he writes about, Udell is able to gather a lot of information about people who go to the same YMCA he does because the ID bar code scanner displays the account record of the last person who used it. So he describes being able to tell his wife, the name, age, etc. of the woman who just went out the door of the YMCA before him.

I had something similar to that happen when I took my grandmother to the doctor several months ago. The front office had a typical u-shaped desk. When you were done seeing the doctor, signs direct you to one side of the desk to make a follow-up appointment. There were several people waiting to make appointments, so there was a small line starting at the front of the u-shaped desk and extending backwards toward the examination rooms.

Which meant I had a clear view of the receptionist’s 20″ monitor and knew that the women at the front of the line had been there to see the doctor about her breast cancer. So much for HIPAA!

Source:

Sidestepping the analog hole. Jon Udell, InfoWorld, March 1, 2006.

Apologetix

Through a strange series of events today I wound up with a copy of a sampler disc for Christian band Apologetix. Normally I’m not exactly a member of the core target market for Christian music, but Apologetix has a clever gimmick — they do Christian parodies of hit pop songs.

I’d say they’re a lot like an evangelical Christian version of Weird Al Yankovic, but the production values and song writing aren’t quite that high. A better description is that this is Christian filk.

The style of music is all over the place from parodies of Simon and Garfunkel’s “Sound of Silence” which becomes “Paul and Silas” to “Enter Sampson”, a takeoff on Metallica’s “Enter Sandman.”

Some of the songs are genuinely clever; many of them are outright groaners. Just like filk. But it’s still much more interesting even at its worst than much of the prefab safe music it parodies.

The group’s website is also a blast. I imagine, for example, that few bands have to include the following on their website faq,

Is the ApologetiX logo a pagan symbol?

Sometimes people inquire about the Trinity symbol we often use, which is prominently displayed on the cover of our “Jesus Christ Morningstar” CD and seen elsewhere on our CDs, t-shirts and other materials.

That symbol is called the “Triquetra” and has long been a symbol of the Trinity — a foundational doctrine of Christianity. That is the main reason we chose this symbol; it reminds us of the Trinity and the deity of Jesus Christ.

The Triquetra is actually printed on the spine of all New King James Version (NKJV) Bibles, and you can also find it in the architecture and stained glass windows of many historical churches. Although that symbol may have had Celtic origins as some New Agers claim, it was assimilated and converted to Christianity in Great Britain about 1000 years ago, in the early 1100’s, and has been primarily a symbol of the Trinity for the last 800 years. In a similar way that the feast days that became Christmas and Easter were originally assimilated and converted from pagan rituals so they now celebrate the birth and bodily resurrection of Christ.

Though it may have been “borrowed” by others, to us and to the church of the last 1,000 years, the Triquetra symbolizes the divine mystery of the Trinity — one God in three persons, the Father, the Son and the Holy Spirit.

Translation: of course it is a pagan symbol, but we’ll pretend it isn’t anyway!

Or this mini-essay on whether or not Christian parodies of pop songs are evil,

Is Christian rock music evil?

We get asked this question frequently, and since our name “ApologetiX” comes from the word “apologetics” which means to give a Christian defense (with gentleness and respect), we had better have an answer!

As a band, we realize that rock and roll is a very powerful tool and can be used for good or evil — just as a gun can be used to enforce or break the law. The Bible says that every good and perfect gift comes from God, and I’m sure we agree that music belonged to God before Satan altered it for his purposes.

. . .As the lyricist for our songs, I know without a doubt that our parodies are a gift from God. I realize that they are not products of my own talents or imagination, but come from Him.

Man, I gotta go to a concert with these guys.

La la Media’s CD Swapping Plan

Reuters has coverage of La la Media Inc’s plan to facilitate swapping of CDs between individuals.

The idea seems to be that you’d register on their site, and then list all the CDs you own as well as ones you want to trade for. You then put the CDs La la Media requests in Netflix-style envelopes and it handles the swap for you for a $1 fee. Reuters even alludes to the Netflix model,

With 1.8 million album titles available, members trade the CDs in prepaid envelopes, much like popular mail-order DVD service Netflix Inc. operates.

There’s just one problem. Like Netflix, this is clearly a rental scheme. Unlike DVDs, it is illegal to offer CDs for rent or lease in the United States thanks to provisions of the 1976 Copyright Act. La la Media Inc. would essentially have to obtain permission of the music companies to move forward with its plan. Good luck.

(This is not, of course, the first such CD swapping attempt. Ongo Bongo announced a swapping scheme back in 2004, but its website still features “coming soon” text).

Source:

Reuters Online music service to let users swap CDs.Sue Zeidler, Reuters, March 7, 2006.

The Babylon Project Was Our Last, Best Hope for Peace. It Failed.

Not being a Christian, in my world the Holy Trinity looks something like this,

1. The Prisoner

2. Buffy: The Vampire Slayer

3. Bablyon 5, the Third Season

I spent about a month and a half watching the 3rd season of B5 over and over on DVD. It got so bad at one point that I was simply sitting and forcing my DVD player to loop those first two lines of the opening credits of Season 3 over and over. Today all I have to do is a start in with the first few words to guarantee a withering look from my wife.

Anyway, something those three series have in common is there aren’t any good videogames for them (yes, I played the B:TVS console games, and no I wasn’t impressed).

But some serious B5 fanboys have put together a freeware B5 game, Babylon 5: I’ve Found Her, that absolutely rocks. This is a space combat simulator that does an excellent job of capturing the look and feel of B5-style space combat (which, like the recent incarnation of Battlestar Galactica, actually pretended to use real physics instead of going all “Top Gun” in space).