After the assassination of President John F. Kennedy in 1963, Malcolm X created a controversy when he characterized the assassination as “chickens coming home to roost.” Malcolm X believed that the United States was a fundamentally violent society, and his point was that in the context of that violence it is hardly surprising that someone would direct violence at the nation’s political leaders.
Harry Browne, the recent Libertarian Party presidential candidate, wrote an article yesterday which bluntly blamed American foreign policy for Tuesday’s terrorist attack,
Our foreign policy has been insane for decades. It was only a matter of time until Americans would have to suffer personally for it. It is a terrible tragedy of life that the innocent so often have to suffer for the sins of the guilty.
When will we learn that we can’t allow our politicians to bully the world without someone bullying back eventually?
President Bush has authorized continued bombing of innocent people in Iraq. President Clinton bombed innocent people in the Sudan, Afghanistan, Iraq, and Serbia. President Bush Senior invaded Iraq and Panama. President Reagan bombed innocent people in Libya and invaded Grenada. And on and on it goes.
Did we think the people who lost their families and friends and property in all that destruction would love America for what happened?
Myles Kantor is outraged in response and claims that this is excusing or justifying the terrorist acts.
I think that is an untenable position. Browne’s point, at least as I read it, isn’t that somehow these terrorists were justified because of U.S. military intervention, but rather that if the United States is going to engage in the killing of innocent people abroad, we are foolish to think that those people won’t try to strike back in a similar fashion.
Kantor says that, “For a libertarian to soft-pedal it [mass murder] is obscene incoherence.” No, Myles, what is obscene is that our government has for far too long been an active participant in exactly the sorts of cowardly terrorist acts that were committed on Tuesday (though rarely on that scale).
George W. Bush says that countries that harbor or stand by and allow such acts to be planned and carried out are just as guilty as the terrorists. Well, where does that leave the United States given that the Central Intelligence Agency not only knew about but clearly provided aid and comfort to the Guatemalan military while it murdered tens of thousands of civilians? How can members of Congress go on television and talk about cowards who murder civilians when they just a few months ago approved a multi-billion dollar package to fight a war against Colombian civilians?
There is no excuse or justification for the 9/11 attacks, and the United States needs to respond appropriately by tracking down and bringing to justice, one way or another, those responsible for that heinous act. But we also need to have empathy and understanding for the civilian victims of the U.S. military and foreign policy and say enough is enough.