Winer’s Wrong about Senate Intelligence Investigation

Dave Winer claims,

Key point about the Senate report on the CIA. They should disclose that they did a deal with the White House that the investigation would not look at them. In other words, everything they’re saying about the CIA probably fully applies to the President. If so, then the solution is clear, vote him out of office in November

This is simply not true. As the New York Times notes, the deal between Senate Democrats and Republicans simply puts the investigation of the White House into a later stage of the investigation,

Under a deal reached this year between Republicans and Democrats, the Bush administration’s role will not be addressed until the Senate Intelligence Committee completes a further stage of its inquiry, but probably not until after the November election. As a result, said the officials, both Democratic and Republican, the committee’s initial, unanimous report will focus solely on misjudgments by intelligence agencies, not the White House, in the assessments about Iraq, illicit weapons and Al Qaeda that the administration used as a rationale for the war.

Source:

Senate Iraq Report Said to Skirt White House Use of Intelligence. Douglas Jehl, New York Times, July 8, 2004.

Blair Suggests Re-Examining Abortion in UK

UK Prime Minister Tony Blair recently made comments that it might be time to look at further reducing the number of weeks at which abortion is allowed in the UK.

Compared to the United States, the UK has rather restrictive abortion laws. Abortion is only allowed until the 24th week unless there is evidence that the fetus will suffer from severe disabilities. Even then, a woman has to have two doctors sign off approval for the abortion procedure.

Apparently a new ultrasound technique resulted in video of a 12-week old fetus moving in the womb. According to the BBC, in response to that Blair said,

I have not had an opportunity myself to study in detail that evidence that has been provided. But I am sure that if the situation does change then it would be advisable for us to have another look at the whole question. If the scientific evidence has shifted then it is obviously sensible for us to take that into account. If we have proposals to put before the House we will put them.

Lord Steel, who was primarily responsible for the 1967 Act that legalized abortion in the UK, is currently pushing to have the 24-week limit reduced to 22 weeks and to remove the requirement that women have two doctors sing off on the abortion.

Source:

Blair hints at abortion rethink. The BBC, July 7, 2004.

Generic AIDS Drugs Work as Well as Brand Name Drugs

The first clinical study of generic AIDS drugs has found that they work as effectively in treating AIDS as the more expensive brand-name versions of the drugs.

The United States has committed $15 billion to fight AIDS, but will not allow any of that money to be spent on generic drugs until they can prove they are as effective as brand name drugs. The World Health Organization and others already purchase and distribute generic AIDS drugs to the developing world.

Researchers followed 60 patines who took a generic version of a pill that combines three different anti-AIDS compounds. Eighty percent of those in the trial saw their virus levels decline to very low levels, consistent with what would be seen with brand-name drugs. Only one patient stopped taking the drug due to side effects.

Source:

Study finds generic AIDS drug effective. Donald G. McNeil, Jr., New York Times, July 2, 2004.

Study Reports Rise in Number of Elective Cesarean Sections

A study by Health Grades Inc. reports that the number of elective cesarean sections increased by 25 percent from 2000 to 2002, and that as many as 1 in 50 live births in the United States are now performed by elective cesarian sections.

The study examined births at 1,684 hospitals and found that 2.21 percent of live births during the study period were performed by elective cesarian sections.

There are also preliminary indications that elective cesarean section births may be more cost effective and have fewer complications than vaginal births. The Health Grades Inc. study found that there were complications in 8.4 percent of elective cesareans as compared to complications in 12 percent of vaginal births.

That figure is in line with a University of Texas study that found elective cesarean births were more cost effective over the long term than vaginal births. Elective cesareans cost $920 compared to only $780 for vaginal births, but the costs of treating complications from vaginal births more than outweighed the slightly higher costs for the cesarean.

Sources:

Study finds Caesarean births more popular. Austin Business Journal, June 28, 2004.

Number of ‘Patient Choice’ C-Sections Rises by 25 Percent, HealthGrades Study Finds. Press Release, Health Grades Inc., June 29, 2004.

Islamic Extremists Stop Female Wrestling in Bangladesh

After demonstrators took to the streets in the capitol of Bangladesh, authorities there cancelled that country’s first scheduled female wrestling tournament.

The state-run wrestling federation hoped to have women from across the country participate in the event, but gave in after protesters complained that wrestling was “indecent and vulgar for Muslim women.”

The BBC reported, however, that the protesters misunderstood the nature of the wrestling match — the women would wrestle fully clothed, rather than wearing WWF-style uniforms or, Allah forbid, shorts.

The BBC quoted wrestling federation director Tabiur Rhaman as saying,

There is a misunderstanding. They might have thought that it would be a tournament like WWF, but we can assure them there will be nothing like that because we are fully aware of our religious sentiments.

Perhaps it is Rhaman, however, who misunderstands the opposition to women wrestling. Take Islamic reactionary Moulana Mohiuddin Khan who the BBC quotes as saying,

We are even ready to sacrifice our lives, if necessary, to protect our country from any kind of indecent sports.

Please, Khan, feel free to make that sacrifice any time.

Source:

Women’s wrestling called off. The BBC, July 4, 2004.

WHO Investigating Possible Polio Outbreak in Nigeria

The UN Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs reports that the World Health Organization is investigating a possible outbreak of polio in the northern Nigerian state of Kano.

Kano officials suspended polio vaccination efforts in 2003 over concerns that the vaccine was a plot against Nigerian Muslims.

Now, 20-30 suspected cases of polio have been reported in the town of Rogo. Meanwhile polio cases also appear to be spreading out from Nigeria into surrounding African nations — a total of 10 African countries that had been certified polio-free have reported at least 1 case of polio in the last 12 months.

All of the latest and best medicine available is still of little avail when met with irrationality and unreason.

Source:

WHO investigates suspected polio outbreak in Kano. United Nations Integrated Regional Information Networks, July 6, 2004.