Getting My ASUS Tablet Fixed

A couple years ago I had an awful experience with HTC trying to get a defective Nexus One fixed. Even though the problem I experienced—a faulty power button—was a known issue with the phone by the time I sent mine in for service, it took almost two months from the time I sent my phone in until I got it back. And, to add insult to injury, it worked for maybe a couple more months before the damn power button began failing again.

So I was very nervous when I went to turn on my ASUS Transformer Prime tablet and instead of a login screen I saw a wavy pattern that looked like someone from The Outer Limits had taken control of the horizontal and vertical controls. The tablet was simply unusable. Since it was about 5 months since I’d purchased it, it was time to get it serviced.

The process started out painlessly enough. I went online, and after a bit of searching found a technical support form where I entered in the type of tablet, the serial, my details and the explanation of the problem. ASUS then sent me an email with a case number and instructions on the next step which was to call and talk to a customer service representative.

One of the major points of frustration throughout my experience — which ended much better than my HTC repair — was that it turned out the online case/tracking system was basically a Potemkin village. It is pretty much for show — not once did anyone from ASUS update the case. Not when I called in, not when the tablet arrived, not when they diagnosed the problem, nor when they ultimately shipped my tablet back. That part of dealing with ASUS was extremely disappointing.

Anyway, I followed the instructions and called and talked to a customer service representative. It wasn’t his fault, but the CSR was clueless about anything tech-related. When I described that the screen had failed — possibly due to a faulty internal video connection — I wasn’t too surprised or annoyed when I was told to turn the device off and back on. But I went through that process several times each time with a conversation like this:

CSR: Has it rebooted yet?

Me: Yes, but the screen is still filled with wavy lines and unreadable.

CSR: Okay, I’m going to need you to go ahead and enter your device password now.

Me: Um, I can’t because the screen is a blob of wavy lines with no text entry box visible.

CSR: Okay, lets go ahead and turn it off again….

I realized I was never going to get anywhere with this person, called back a little later and obtained an RMA. I sent in on a Thursday and it arrived the following Tuesday at the ASUS repair service.

Which is when I expected them to update the online service information, but they didn’t. The next day it still hadn’t been updated so I called and asked for a status update. All the CSR could tell me was that it was in their service department. No word on if they found the problem or if it was covered by the warranty.

A couple days more days went buy and still no updates when I receive an email that my tablet is being shipped by UPS ground back to me. Does this mean it was fixed? No clue. Again, no updates to the system that ASUS said I could go to and track the progress of the repair.

A day later it arrived at my door, fixed and working fine. The online service tracking case was never updated so I have no idea what the problem was. There was a paper insert with the tablet outlining the various steps of the repair process, but they basically lists of part numbers with what appeared to be internal ASUS codes.

On the one hand, ASUS did a tremendous job of repairing my tablet and shipping it back to me much more quickly than I anticipated. On the other hand, I’m amazed that companies don’t realize how annoying it is for customers to be waiting in the dark not having any idea what’s going on.

HTC Could Care Less About Its Customers

I have a Nexus One…well, I used to have a Nexus One, but the power button stopped working and I sent it back to HTC to fix it. Except HTC would rather play games and give me misleading information rather than fix my phone. As of the day this was published, HTC “express repair” has had my phone for 14 days, and has yet to do anything beyond do an initial scan that it was received. No analysis, much less repair work, has been done on my phone and HTC cannot give me any hard and fast timeframe on when they might actually get around to fixing the known issue with the phone.

This is an e-mail I sent to HTC’s public relations department as well as The Consumerist,

Back on February 3, I purchased a Nexus One through Google, with the understanding that HTC would be responsible for repairs.

A few weeks ago, my phone developed a problem that according to reports on the Internet and from your CSRs is fairly common with the phone — the power button
began to fail. I would press it, and it wouldn’t turn off or on immediately. Finally, on June 20, 2010 the power button failed altogether.

Not a problem, I thought. I’ll just call up HTC and get it fixed. I was offered a chance to get a new/refurbished phone shipped to me and then ship my existing phone back, or do an “express repair.” Since I was told “express repair” was typically 4 to 5 business days, I opted for that.

HTC scanned my as received on June 23, 2010 (HTC Ticket: [omitted for blog post]). And, as far as I can tell, hasn’t done a damn thing with it since.

I began calling support for updates the following week. Typically, I’d call on a Tuesday and be told call back on Wednesday. I’d call back on Wednesday and be told, oh it will probably be done Thursday — call back then. Then I was told, don’t worry, it will probably be finished by July 5, but things just aren’t being updated in our database, so call back then.

Alas, despite repeated calls, no updates beyond “yes we received your phone.”

Today, however, I talked to a nice CSR who explained to me that HTC had me ship the phone to their repair center in Texas at PRECISELY THE TIME THEY WERE MOVING THAT REPAIR CENTER TO STAFFORD. Are you kidding me?

But it gets better. So I’m told by HTC CSRs that phones that were sent to Houston for repair have basically not yet been looked at. That they just sat at Houston for awhile awaiting to be redirected to Stafford. According to your CSR, if I’m lucky a technician at your Stafford center *might* finally take my
phone out of the box and examine it on July 8 or July 9.

That is, frankly, a ridiculous timetable and the lack of accurate information and tracking in this case has been absolutely bizarre. I’m tempted to just say screw it and grab a Samsung Vibrant when T-Mobile releases that on July 21, as it appears increasingly unlikely I won’t have my Nexus One back by then.

Is there anything you can do to rectify this situation?

Thank you,

Brian Carnell

P.S. you may want to reconsider your Twitter engagement (or complete lack thereof). It is very frustrating to try to engage @HTC on Twitter and realize its just a corporate PR tool account … even my cable company engages me (very helpfully) when I try to communicate with it on Twitter.