Activist Pleads Not Guilty to Trespassing, Obstruction

New Jersey animal rights activist Angi Metler, 47, plead not guilty this month to charges of trespassing and obstructing a government function. Metler locked herself to a bear trap in August and police had to remove part of the cage to arrest her.

According to the New Jersey Herald, Metler and another activist with Bear Education and Resource Group visited a home that had recently been broken into by a bear. State wildlife officials had set up a trap outside the home in hopes the bear would return.

The New Jersey Herald reported that,

Words were apparently exchanged between [the homeowner] and the activists, and Metler’s solution was to jump into the cage to prevent the death of the bear, which would be killed if caught and positively identified as the problem animal.

Wildlife officials believe that one or two bears is responsible for numerous home break-ins in the area.

Source:

Caged BEAR activist ready to go to trial. Brendan Berls, New Jersey Herald, September 1, 2004.

New Jersey Assemblyman Introduces Black Bear Hunt Bans

New Jersey Assemblyman Anthony Chiappone this month introduced two bills in that would ban black bear hunting in that state and require the New Jersey Fish and Game Council to study alternatives to hunting to control the black bear population.

Assembly Bill 2634 reads in part that,

The Fish and Game Council shall, within 18 months after the date of enactment of this act, conduct a study setting forth (1) the status and management of the black bear population in the State, (2) an analysis of the population growth of black bear in the State, and (3) information on the availability, effectiveness, and implementation of alternative black bear population control methods, reproductive control methods, and sterilization control methods. Upon completion of this study, the State Fish and Game Council shall submit a written report to the Department of Environmental Protection, the Governor, and both Houses of the Legislature.

And just to show that he’s serious about making sure the matter gets thoroughly studied, Chiappone’s bill would allocate the sum of $95,000 to the Fish and Game Council for said study.

The full text of Assembly Bill 2634 can be read here.

Chiappone also introduced Assembly Bill 2704 which would simply ban bear hunting, period, and set up a group separate from the Fish and Game Council to manage black bear populations in the state. That bill has some interesting language (emphasis added),

There is established a Black Bear Study Commission, which shall comprise 11 members as follows: two veterinarians licensed in the State of New Jersey, having experience with black bears, who shall be appointed by the Governor; a representative of the Humane Society of the United States, who shall be appointed by that organization; a representative of the Bear Education and Resource Group, who shall be appointed by that organization; a representative of persons residing in those areas of the State where black bear are regularly found, who shall be appointed by the governing body of West Milford Township in Passaic County; a representative of the Sierra Club, who shall be appointed by that organization; a representative of the Mountain Preservation Society, who shall be appointed by that organization; a member of the Nature Preservation Council, who shall be appointed by that organization; a representative of the Farm Bureau, who shall be appointed by that organization; an animal control officer having experience with black bears, who shall be appointed by the governor; and a representative of the Department of Environmental Protection, who shall be appointed by that agency. The Governor shall appoint the Chair.

Now there’s a great idea — give an animal rights group like HSUS a permanent position on a council that for the next five years would play a major role in setting bear management policies.

This writer wholeheartedly agrees with U.S. Sportsmen’s Alliance field director Tony Celebrezze who said in a press release on the bills that,

These bills eliminate science from wildlife management, eradicating the bear hunt without presenting a scientific or biological basis for doing so. Hunting is the most effective bear management tool and it should not be discarded because of the emotional rhetoric of anti-hunters.

The full text of Assembly Bill 2704 can be read here.

Sources:

New Jersey bills will prohibit black bear hunt. Press Release, U.S. Sportsmen’s Alliance, May 14, 2004.

New Jersey Assembly Bill 2704 – Black Bear Hunt Ban

 

ASSEMBLY, No. 2704

 

STATE OF NEW JERSEY

 

211th LEGISLATURE

 

INTRODUCED MAY 6, 2004

 

 

Sponsored by:

Assemblyman ANTHONY CHIAPPONE

District 31 (Hudson)

 

 

 

 

SYNOPSIS

    Prohibits black bear hunting, creates black bear study commission,
authorizes issuance and sale of NJ Black Bear Stamp, establishes NJ Black
Bear Stamp Account.

 

CURRENT VERSION OF TEXT

    As introduced.

 

An Act concerning the hunting of black bear, supplementing Title 23
of the Revised Statutes
, and making an appropriation.

 

    Be It Enacted by the Senate and General Assembly of the State
of New Jersey:

 

    1. Not withstanding any law, rule, regulation, or provision of the
State Fish and Game Code, there shall be no open season or any
hunting by permit for black bears anywhere in the State.

 

    2. a. There is established a Black Bear Study Commission, which
shall comprise 11 members as follows: two veterinarians licensed in
the State of New Jersey,
having experience with black bears, who
shall be appointed by the Governor; a representative of the Humane
Society of the United States, who shall be appointed by that
organization; a representative of the Bear Education and Resource
Group, who shall be appointed by that organization; a representative
of persons residing in those areas of the State where black bear are
regularly found, who shall be appointed by the governing body of
West Milford Township in Passaic County; a representative of the
Sierra Club, who shall be appointed by that organization; a
representative of the Mountain Preservation Society, who shall be
appointed by that organization; a member of the Nature Preservation
Council, who shall be appointed by that organization; a representative
of the Farm Bureau, who shall be appointed by that organization; an
animal control officer having experience with black bears, who shall
be appointed by the governor; and a representative of the Department
of Environmental Protection, who shall be appointed by that agency.
The Governor shall appoint the Chair.

    b. Members of the commission shall serve at the pleasure of the
relevant appointing authority.

    c. Vacancies in the appointed positions on the commission shall
be filled in the same manner as the original appointments.

    d. Members of the commission shall serve without compensation,
but the commission may, within the limits of funds appropriated or
otherwise made available to it, reimburse members for actual
expenses necessarily incurred in the discharge of their official duties.

 

    3. a. The commission shall organize as soon as possible after the
appointment of its members and shall meet at such times and places
as it deems appropriate.

    b. A majority of the full membership of the commission shall
constitute a quorum for the transaction of commission business.
Action may be taken and motions and resolutions adopted by the
commission at any meeting thereof by the affirmative vote of a
majority of the full membership of the commission.

    c. The commission shall be entitled to call to its assistance and
avail itself of the services and assistance of such officials and
employees of the State and its political subdivisions and their
departments, boards, bureaus, commissions, authorities, and agencies
as it may require and as may be available to it for its purposes, and
incur traveling and other miscellaneous expenses as it may deem
necessary, in order to perform its duties, and may expend any funds
as may be appropriated or otherwise made available to it for its
purposes.
       d. Prior to preparing the initial report required pursuant
to section 4 of this act, the commission shall hold at least one public
hearing to solicit public input on the issues under the jurisdiction of
the commission.

 

    4. a. The commission shall, within one year after the date of
enactment of this act, and quarterly each year for the next four years
thereafter, prepare and issue a written report, which may include
recommendations to be made to the Governor, the Legislature, the
Department of Environmental Protection, and the Department of
Agriculture, concerning (1) the status and management of the black
bear population in the State, and (2) the availability, effectiveness,
implementation, and use of nonlethal black bear population control
methods, reproductive control procedures, aversive conditioning
techniques, and public education and training efforts and programs to
reduce, to the maximum extent practicable and feasible, actual and
potential conflicts between black bears and humans. Copies of each
commission report shall be made available to the public at no cost.

    b. For the period during which it exists, the commission shall
advise the Department of Environmental Protection with respect to the
creation, design, administration, sale, distribution, and other matters
related to the New Jersey Black Bear Stamp, and the reproduction,
replica, or other utilization of its design, authorized pursuant to
section 6 of this act. The commission shall also advise the
Department of Environmental Protection with respect to the
utilization of revenues in the New Jersey Black Bear Stamp Account
established pursuant to section 7 of this act.

    c. The commission shall expire five years after the date of
enactment of this act.

 

    5. There is appropriated from the General Fund to the Black Bear
Study Commission the sum of $10,000 to carry out the purposes of
this act.

 

    6. a. The Department of Environmental Protection is authorized
to issue annually a Black Bear Stamp, which may be procured from
the department or from other designated agents deemed qualified by
the department. The fee for the New Jersey Black Bear Stamp shall
be $10.

    b. The department shall determine the final design and form of the
New Jersey Black Bear Stamp to be issued each year. The department
shall retain reproduction and distribution rights to the design of any
New Jersey Black Bear Stamp issued.

    c. The sole purpose for issuance of the New Jersey Black Bear
Stamp shall be to raise revenue for the purposes set forth in section 7
of this act.

 

    7. a. There is established within the Department of Environmental
Protection a separate and dedicated account to be known as the “New
Jersey Black Bear Stamp Account.” The account shall be credited
with all revenues received by the department from the sale of the New
Jersey Black Bear Stamp and of any reproduction, replica, or other
utilization of the design of the stamp. Moneys in the account shall be
utilized by the Department of Environmental Protection, in
consultation with the Department of Agriculture, to (1) compensate
farmers for documented damage or injury to, or loss of, agricultural
or horticultural crops, livestock, or other personal or real property due
to black bear activity, and (2) assist in paying the cost of public
education and training efforts and programs to reduce, to the
maximum extent practicable and feasible, actual and potential
conflicts between black bears and humans.

    b. The New Jersey Black Bear Stamp Account shall be kept
separate and apart from all other funds and accounts, and moneys
shall be disbursed therefrom by the State Treasurer to the Department
of Environmental Protection only for the purposes identified in this
section.

 

    8. The Department of Environmental Protection may adopt,
pursuant to the “Administrative Procedure Act,” P.L.1968, c.410
(C.52:14B-1 et seq.), any rules and regulations necessary to
administer the provisions of sections 6 and 7 of this act, including, but
not limited rules and regulations pertaining to, (1) the creation,
design, administration, sale, distribution, and establishment of prices
for any reproduction, replica, or other utilization of the design of any
New Jersey Black Bear Stamp issued, and (2) the distribution of
moneys from the New Jersey Black Bear Stamp Account established
pursuant to section 7 of this act.

 

    9. This act shall take effect immediately.

 

 

STATEMENT

 

    This bill would prohibit any open season hunting or any hunting by
permit of black bear in the State. In addition, this bill would create
an 11-member Black Bear Study Commission, composed of
representatives of various interest groups, who would be charged with
preparing, within one year and quarterly for four years thereafter, a
written report concerning (1) the status and management of the black
bear population in the State, and (2) the availability, effectiveness,
implementation, and use of nonlethal black bear population control
methods, reproductive control procedures, aversive conditioning
techniques, and public education and training efforts and programs to
reduce, to the maximum extent practicable and feasible, actual and
potential conflicts between black bears and humans. The bill would
require the commission to hold at least one public hearing prior to the
preparation of its initial report to solicit public input on the issues
under jurisdiction of the commission. Each report may include
recommendations to be made to the Governor, the Legislature, and
various State agencies. The commission would expire in five years.

    The bill would appropriate $10,000 to the Black Bear Study
Commission to carry out its duties under the legislation.

    In addition, the bill would authorize the Department of
Environmental Protection to issue annually a New Jersey Black Bear
Stamp, which may be procured from the department or from other
designated agents deemed qualified by the department. The fee for
the stamp would be $10. The department would retain reproduction
and distribution rights to the design of any New Jersey Black Bear
Stamp issued. The stamps would be sold solely for fund-raising
purposes as prescribed in the bill.

    Finally, the bill would establish the “New Jersey Black Bear Stamp
Account,” which would be credited with all revenues received by the
Department of Environmental Protection from the sale of the New
Jersey Black Bear Stamp and of any reproduction, replica, or other
utilization of the design of the stamp. Moneys in the account would
be utilized by the Department of Environmental Protection, in
consultation with the Department of Agriculture, to (1) compensate
farmers for documented damage or injury to, or loss of, agricultural
or horticultural crops, livestock, or other personal or real property due
to black bear activity, and (2) assist in paying the cost of public
education and training efforts and programs to reduce, to the
maximum extent practicable and feasible, actual and potential
conflicts between black bears and humans.

New Jersey Assembly Bill 2634 – Ban on Bear Hunting

 

ASSEMBLY, No. 2634

 

STATE OF NEW JERSEY

 

211th LEGISLATURE

 

INTRODUCED MAY 3, 2004

 

 

Sponsored by:

Assemblyman ANTHONY CHIAPPONE

District 31 (Hudson)

 

 

 

 

SYNOPSIS

    Prohibits black bear hunting for five years and until study is issued by Fish
and Game Council; appropriates $95,000.

 

CURRENT VERSION OF TEXT

    As introduced.

 

An Act concerning the hunting of black bear and making an
appropriation.

 

    Be It Enacted by the Senate and General Assembly of the State
of New Jersey:

 

    1. a. Notwithstanding any law, rule, regulation, or provision of the
State Fish and Game Code to the contrary, there shall be no open
season nor any hunting by permit for black bear anywhere in the State
prior to five years after the effective date of this act and until a study
is conducted by the New Jersey Fish and Game Council pursuant to
subsection b. of this section.

    b. The Fish and Game Council shall, within 18 months after the
date of enactment of this act, conduct a study setting forth (1) the
status and management of the black bear population in the State, (2)
an analysis of the population growth of black bear in the State, and (3)
information on the availability, effectiveness, and implementation of
alternative black bear population control methods, reproductive
control methods, and sterilization control methods. Upon completion
of this study, the State Fish and Game Council shall submit a written
report to the Department of Environmental Protection, the Governor,
and both Houses of the Legislature.

 

    2. There is appropriated from the General Fund to the Fish and
Game Council the sum of $95,000 to carry out the purposes of this
act.

 

    3. This act shall take effect immediately.

 

 

STATEMENT

 

    This bill would impose a statutory moratorium on black bear
hunting in the State for five years after the date of enactment of this
bill and require the State Fish and Game Council to conduct a study
on the black bear population in the State.

    The provisions of the bill would provide that the Fish and Game
Council shall, within 18 months after the enactment of this bill,
conduct a study setting forth (1) the status and management of the
black bear population in the State, (2) an analysis of the population
growth of black bear in the State, and (3) information on the
availability, effectiveness, and implementation of alternative black
bear population control methods, reproductive control methods, and
sterilization control methods.
Upon completion of this study, the
State Fish and Game Council shall submit a written report to the
Department of Environmental Protection, the Governor, and both
Houses of the Legislature.

    This bill also would appropriate $95,000 to the Fish and Game
Council for the preparation and completion of the study.

Maryland DNR Rejects $75,000 from Fund for Animals and HSUS

The Fund for Animals and the Humane Society of the United States made a financial offer to the Maryland Department of Natural Resources in March: withdraw plans for a Fall bear hunt season, and the two groups would donate $75,000 to the DNR to compensate property owners for damage from bears as well as help education Maryland residents on managing bear-human conflict.

On April 14, the Maryland DNR said it was willing to accept the $75,000 from the groups but could not agree to the stipulation that the bear hunt season be withdrawn,

The Maryland Department of Natural Resources (DNR) today accepted a funding offer from the Fund for Animals and the Humane Society of the United States to mitigate bear and human conflicts. While accepting the funding, DNR rejected the stipulation that the proposed bear hunting season be cancelled.

The funding offer, $75,000 in total, would be used to further the financial resources DNR currently dedicates for bear damage compensation and bear-human conflict management. Specifically, these funds would be used to compensate individuals who document bear damage and to implement an aversive conditioning and bear education campaign in bear-occupied areas.

“While we may not agree on the hunting regulation proposal, I hope that the Fund for Animals and Humane Society of the United StatesÂ’ commitment to assist us is sincere and that we can count on their financial and philosophical support for the remaining non-lethal and education strategies in our bear management plan,” said DNR Wildlife & Heritage Service Director Paul A. Peditto.

This was, in this writer’s opinion, a clever strategy to take, especially Peditto’s comments when he had to know full well that HSUS and the Fund would both interpret this as a rejection. Oddly, the conservative Washington Times ran an op-ed by Gene Mueller who completely missed the point here> Mueller chastised the DNR for getting into bed with animal rights groups and wrote,

I’ll wager the well-heeled Fund for Animals and the Humane Society are having parties right now, celebrating the fact that they got a foot into the door of an agency that regulates all the hunting and fishing of an American state.

Hardly. In fact The Fund for Animals and Humane Society of the United States released a press release the same day noting that the DNR had rejected its offer,

The Fund for Animals and The Humane Society of the United States learned today that the Maryland Department of Natural Resources (DNR) has rejected a substantial financial offer for solving bear conflicts and compensating farmers for bear damage. In a March 17 letter, the two organizations offered collectively to provide $75,000 to compensate farmers for bear damage and expand educational programs to solve bear conflicts, if the DNR’s plan for the first bear hunt in fifty years was withdrawn.

In that press release, Fund president Mark Markarian said,

It is clear that the DNR is not seeking to solve bear conflicts in western Maryland, but simply to put bears in trophy hunters’ sights. Hunting bears for trophies or rugs will not provide money to farmers and will not provide the relief that citizens are demanding. Governor Ehrlich’s administration should look for constructive solutions and new funding partnerships, not trophy hunting opportunities.

And HSUS senior vice president Wayne Pacelle offered this bit of trivia,

There are fewer black bears in Maryland than there are pandas in China or endangered grizzly bears in Montana.

I’m not sure what the population of pandas in a country the size of China has to do with the population of bears in a state the size of Maryland, but such comparisons probably makes perfect sense to animal rights activists.

Sources:

DNR, animal rights groups in bed. Gene Mueller, The Washington Times, April 21, 2004.

Maryland Rejects $75,000 Offer To Cancel Bear Hunt. Press Release, The Fund for Animals, April 14, 2004.

Letter to DNR Offering $75,000 for Solving Bear Problems. Letter, Michael Markarian, Fund for Animals, March 17, 2004.

DNR Accepts Funding From HSUS, Fund for Animals. Press Release, Maryland Department of Natural Resources, April 14, 2004.

European Union Suspends Import of Grizzly Bear Hunting Trophies from British Columbia

In January, the European Union suspended the import of grizzly bear hunting trophies from British Columbia.

The European Union had repeatedly threatened such action — as recently as June 2003 it told British Columbia that it would take such an action if British Columbia did not establish hunting-free reserves for grizzly bears by December 1, 2003.

Environmental groups have pressured the European Union for years to take such action, contending that the grizzly bear is already threatened in the United States and that it should pressure British Columbia to stop the hunt of grizzly bears there. In fact, the European Union suspended import of grizzly bear trophies in December 2001, though later lifted that measure.

Bette Stallman of the Humane Society of the United States said in press release that the continued hunting of grizzlies in British Columbia may threaten grizzly populations in the United States,

Immigration of BC grizzlies across the border into the U.S. is crucial for the future viability of the small U.S. grizzly populations. We hope that the EU’s decision will inspire the British Columbian government to act to protect the grizzlies in BC.

Sources:

European Union Decides to Suspend Imports of Grizzly Bear Hunting Trophies from British Columbia. Environmental Investigation Agency and the Humane Society of the United States, January 23, 2004.