There’s an interesting story at Slashdot about a debacle involving an OS X update CD. The CD is free and is supposed to let users upgrade their software from OS X to OS X.1. The upgrade CD allows users to do a clean install, but only after the updater does a check to make sure you already have OS X on your Mac.
But some clever users discovered that there is a single file in the installer package which performs this check. Create an image of the upgrade CD, delete that one file, and then burn the image onto a CD, and the result is a free OS X CD.
Apple was not to happy, going so far as to send out a cease and desist order to a web site that posted instructions on how to do it (though the process is so simple, that you could probably train a monkey to do it — there’s no way they’re going to be able to contain this).
On the one hand, Apple was trying to do the right thing by allowing a clean install — upgrade CDs that don’t allow this are a pain in the ass. On the other hand, it’s hard to be sympathetic over Apple’s intellectual property claims considering its half-assed job at providing digital rigts management on the iPod.
When the iPod was first released I was ranting about it having a DRM scheme built in. But the actual system used by the iPod is so blatantly weak, it was clearly intended to placate lawyers who might consider suing Apple while also ensuring that Mac geeks would be able to bypass the DRM “feature” with ease (just like the upgrade CD, a well-trained monkey should be able to bypass the iPod’s DRM).
I really don’t care which approach Apple takes, but its a bit hypocritical of it to release one product that makes it ridiculously easy to pirate music, and then turn around and whine and moan when someone figures out a way to easily pirate its operating system.